Author: Fiona Broome

[This list is continued from Ghosts of Coastal Maine, Part 1.]

Maine is one of my favorite states, not just because it features one of America’s most beautiful coastlines, but also because it has such a rich history and many ghosts.

Most towns in Maine seem to have ghost stories, though some of Maine’s ghosts are more famous than others.
Here are a few more documented sightings that make Maine one of America’s most delightfully haunted states:

• Thomaston – Josiah Thurston House, Rte. 73
  Lawyer Josiah Thurston began to build his grand Thomaston house in 1855 to impress the politicians he hoped to join in Washington. He was offered an appointment by the President, but the Civil War broke out before the position was secured. After the War, Thurston found himself bankrupted by the expense of his still-unfinished house. He sold the house and became a sailor. He is seen today in his seaman’s clothing, watching people from the roof of his former home.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 45.)

• Thomaston – the “house of healing”
  An 1830 house in Thomaston, dubbed the “house of healing” because it has been the home of three doctors (and their practices), and a boarding house.This house is not dramatically haunted, but the ghost of Walter James (one of the founders of Thomaston Bank, among his many accomplishments) slams windows closed, unlocks doors, and generally gives visitors a sense that they’re “being watched.”

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 33.)

• Port Clyde – Lighthouse Road
  The lighthouse road is haunted by a blond teenager named Ben Bennett and his murderer, a dark-haired bearded man who runs silently down the road in black boots, carrying a knife. The attacker is reputed to be an early 20th-century rum runner who caught young Bennett watching his smuggling.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 9.)

• Northport – “house that wasn’t there”
  In a tragic fire in December 1954, the estate home of the Edward Cosgroves burned to the ground, killing their two children and the couple that was taking care of them that evening. All that remained after the fire was the stubble of one (of two) chimneys, and some children’s items. Soon after the fire, someone took a photograph of the scene, but the print showed the house as it was before the fire. Many others have taken pictures at the site, with the same results, and Northport has become a stopping point for curious visitors ever since. Others have claimed to hear the ghostly screams of the children, from where the house once stood. Author Carol Olivieri Schulte reports that one photo of “the house that wasn’t there” is on the wall of the diner at Northport.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 63.)

• Wiscasset – High Street: Smith House and the Musical Wonder House
  The Smith House on High St. in Wiscasset has long been known for having a ghostly old woman who rocks in a chair by the window. Next door, the Musical Wonder House, a museum of music boxes, also has a ghost. He is rarely seen but often sensed, and appears to be a young man in his late teens or early 20s.

  (Source: Smith, Haunted Houses for the Millions, p. 45.)

• Wiscasset – Eastwind Restaurant
  This restaurant on the main street of the town was built by Charles Dana. The ghost is Lydia, also called “Mother Dana,” who may have been Mr. Dana’s wife or mother. She opens latched doors, manifests other poltergeist phenomena, and—as of 1966—has pushed and shoved owner Dorothy Apgar many times, resulting in broken bones.

  (Source: Smith, Haunted Houses for the Millions, p. 47.)

• Pemaquid – Ft. William HenryWisps of light, sudden cold drafts, and a sad man seen walking one foot above the ground are reportedly among the ghostly manifestations of Taukolexis, an Indian who died in the Fort’s prison in July 1696.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 69.)

• Wreck Island – four miles SW of Friendship Harbor
  Lights and the forms of people outlined in light are seen at Wreck Island at night. They are the eleven passengers of the Winnebec, which went down in a December 1768 storm. They may have drowned before washing ashore or been killed by some fishermen for their belongings. It is said that the fishermen each experienced the sensation of being strangled, shortly after the 1768 disaster, and many of them said their attackers were people in drenched clothing, surrounded by white light.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 57.)

• Monhegan Island – Burnt Head ledges
  A woman reported being pushed by unseen hands, towards the edge of the ledges. One possible ghost might be an 80-year-old woman who leaped to her planned death at this site in 1947.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 39.)

• Orr’s Island
  The spectre ship, Harpswell, has been seen near this island.

  (Source: Snow, Strange Tales…, p. 221.)

Several of these chilling legends are featured in Ghosts on the Coast of Maine, by Carol Olivieri Schulte, (c)1989, Down East Books. If you’re interested in Yankee ghosts and their histories, this book is a delightful read.  It includes far more details than we’ve shared here.

Haunted coastal Maine has so many ghosts and eerie legends, I could probably spend a month researching each town. Maybe more.

Most Maine towns (and each cemetery) has at least one good “ghost story.”

Here are a few documented hauntings. (This list starts at the New Hampshire border, and continues up the coastline.)

Unless noted otherwise, these legends are from the references listed. I include them so that other researchers can investigate them, and because they’re great stories and provide starting points for further study.

For my original New England research, see our other articles at this website.

• York, Maine – Old York Cemetery

  

  According to several books, Mary Miller Jason, a “witch,” haunts the Old York Cemetery since her 1774 death. She was known as an herbalist and an exorcist in her lifetime. It is said that the crows which frequent the cemetery near her gravestone, are her “familiars.”

(Primary source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 143.)

I believe that’s a typo in the book. During my research visit to the Old York Cemetery, I found the headstone for Mary Nasson, d. 1774, which is supposed to be haunted.

It otherwise matches the description provided by Ms. Schulte.

For more information about this “witch” grave and nearby haunts, see my articles, Haunted York, Maine – Mary Nasson’s grave, and Haunted ‘Old Burying Yard’ – York, Maine.

• Scarborough – Massacre Pond (formerly Black Point)
  The bloody ghost of Richard “Crazy Eye” Stonewall is seen at the pond where he was buried in Oct. 1697. Mr. Stonewall’s wife and infant son had been killed by Indians, and he avenged their deaths by joining the military and killing every Indian he found.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 125.)

  (Don’t confuse the ghost Richard “Crazy Eye” Stonewall with a New Hampshire ghost, Richard “Salt Eye” Storr.)

• Freeport – Desert of Maine

The “Desert of Maine” is now a tourist attraction, but it is the product of the ghostly work of Thomas Grayson, who bought the 300-acre farm in 1797. Upon his death, Mr. Grayson made his second wife promise to give the farm to his son, David.

Instead, the farm was given to the widow’s own son from a previous marriage.

Everything seemed fine for the first dozen years or so. Then one day, a small saucer-sized ring of sand appeared to have been pushed up from the soil near the barn. The sand grew daily, and eventually covered all of the formerly fertile land, including trees, plows, the springhouse, and even part of the barn.

At its worst, 800 acres were covered with sandy dunes and valleys.

(Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 119.)

• Edgecomb – Boothbay Harbor region
  Marie Antoinette’s ghost supposedly haunts the home of the late Arthur Clark and his wife. He claimed to have been part of a conspiracy to smuggle the Queen of France to Maine, and a ship loaded with the Queen’s possessions had been sent to Edgecomb. Mr. Clark’s home was soon filled with furniture, paintings, sculptures, and other valuables. It appears the late Queen of France isn’t pleased.  In addition, this story accounts for some extraordinary French antiques that appear in auctions and antique shops in this part of Maine.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 75.)

• Rockland – the former location of Jewell’s Boutique
  This shop, formerly a funeral home, is haunted by a ghost named “George,” perhaps George Golden, who — according to legend — was killed in a car accident on his way to serve in the military in Viet Nam. George moves items in the store, and closes doors, among other poltergeist-type manifestations.

  (Source of Boutique legend: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 15.)

  Additional notes: A reader reports that the house was originally a hospital. Then, Mr. Davis bought it, and it became a funeral parlor. Jewel’s Boutique was the third owner of the haunted house. Today, the shop is a private office.

  This reader also spoke with the former owner of the funeral home and Jewel herself. She says that the ghost is the doctor who ran the hospital. The ghost not only opens and closes doors and moves furniture, but he also pinches the bottoms of the ladies.

  The former funeral parlor owner checked his records and found no notes concerning anyone named George Golden. He reports no other stories about a man tragically killed on his way to the military during the Viet Nam era.

• Lincolnville – Mt. Megunticook Trail
  13-year-old Sarah Whitesell’s translucent apparition appears at the top of the mountain at “Maiden’s Cliff,” where she fell to her death while picking flowers in May 1865. She appeared most frequently in the 1930s and 40s. Her last documented appearance at the mountain was in 1976.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 21.)

• Bucksport – Bucksport Cemetery
  A friend of Hollow Hill and a former resident of Lincoln, Maine, reports that Bucksport Cemetery is very haunted. Judge Buck’s grave bears the mark of a foot, the result of a curse placed upon him when he sentenced a witch to death. During this reader’s four years in Bucksport, she recalls the judge’s headstone being changed at least twice, and the foot reappeared on each new stone, no matter what was done to remove the mark.

• Bucksport – Another cemetery
  The directions are, “Taking one of the back roads out of town, there is a large water reserve with a cemetery directly across from it.” The reader says that a young woman was decapitated in the 1960s and her head thrown in the reservoir. However, her body was not found; it’s assumed that it was washed out to sea. On foggy nights, many residents have seen the headless ghost of this young woman, wandering on this road, looking for her head.

• Bucksport – Captain’s House, Bridge Street
  Another reader has witnessed ghostly manifestations in this house, which is a captain’s house, not named the “Captain’s House.” It’s a particular style of building that allowed several wives of seafarers to live in one building, while keeping separate quarters. Today, these buildings are often used as apartments. The reader witnessed knocking sounds, a feeling as if she was being watched, and the water being turned on in an upstairs bathroom when no one was there. She reported marks like blood had dripped on the fireplace and numerous other frightening manifestations. Before she left, the spirit in the house was “sent back to Hell where it belonged,” by the prayers of several men from church. After moving out of this house, the new owner of the home found two skeletons in the basement, apparently teenage girls from the late 19th century.

• Rockport – the bridge that crosses the Goose River
  Since 1920, the ghost of Revolutionary War hero William Richardson has appeared at a bridge in Rockport, near “lovers’ lane.” Mr. Richardson is a jovial ghost, usually offering a pitcher of ale to anyone he encounters. He was killed at the Goose River bridge by three Tories who were enraged by his celebrating, at the time of the Revolution.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 51.)

• Tenant’s Harbor – East Wind Inn
  Haunted by the ghost of Gilbert Armstrong, co-owner of shipbuilders Armstrong & Keane in the era of the three-masted schooners. His ghost is seen climbing the main staircase, and his footsteps are heard even when nothing can be seen on the stairs. Windows are closed with a slam, breaking the glass. Doors swing, unaccountably. There may be other ghosts in the Inn, as well. In 1987, a guest cheerfully claimed that she’d been held firmly in her bed by a ghost, putting pressure on top of her.

  (Source: Schulte, Ghosts..Coast of Maine, p. 27.)

This list of legends and spooky places continues on our next page, More ghosts of coastal Maine